VancouverCedar Roofing

Comparison

Cedar shake vs asphalt shingle roofing in Vancouver

By Vancouver Cedar Roofing ·

The honest answer is that neither roof wins. Cedar lasts longer and looks better on the right house; asphalt costs less and asks for less. Which one is correct depends on the structure, the budget and whether maintenance will actually happen.

Lifespan

A cedar roof that is cleaned and treated on schedule can reach 30 years or more in the Lower Mainland; some go well beyond that. An asphalt shingle roof of decent grade typically gives 20 to 25 years here. If neither roof is maintained, the gap narrows — moss damages cedar quickly, and asphalt loses granules and curls regardless.

One practical difference: cedar can be repaired in sections almost indefinitely. Asphalt is repairable too, but once a shingle field starts to fail across a slope, matching and patching stops being worthwhile sooner.

Cost over the life of the roof

Cedar costs more to install, and it needs paid maintenance — cleaning every two to three years, treatment, occasional repairs. Asphalt costs less up front and asks for very little until it starts to fail.

The comparison only makes sense over decades. Cedar’s longer service life offsets part of its higher price, but only if the maintenance actually happens. A cedar roof that is never cleaned is more expensive than asphalt on both counts.

Weight and what is underneath

Cedar shake is heavy. That matters on older homes where the roof structure was not designed for it, and it is one reason a structural check belongs in any cedar replacement conversation. Cedar shingle is lighter than shake but still heavier than asphalt.

Asphalt is the lighter option and usually the simpler swap when a structure is marginal. If a house has carried cedar for decades, the structure has already proven it can take the load — but that should be confirmed, not assumed.

Appearance and resale

This is subjective, and it cuts both ways. Cedar has a depth and texture that asphalt cannot imitate, and on character homes and in older west-side neighbourhoods it is what the architecture expects. On a newer suburban house, cedar may read as an expensive oddity rather than an upgrade.

Buyers notice roof condition more than roof material. A well-maintained asphalt roof generally helps a sale more than a tired cedar roof with visible moss, and a documented cedar roof with a maintenance history helps more than either.

Maintenance burden

Cedar is a maintenance roof. Moss removal, treatment, valley clearing and periodic repairs are part of ownership, not optional extras. If you are not going to arrange that work, cedar is the wrong choice regardless of how it looks.

Asphalt is closer to fit-and-forget until the end of its life, with gutter cleaning and the occasional storm repair. That lower attention requirement is a real benefit for rentals, busy households and anyone who does not want a roofer on the roof every few years.

Insurance and fire performance

Asphalt is the easier conversation with insurers. Wood shake attracts more scrutiny in BC, particularly near the forest interface, because untreated cedar is combustible. Treated or rated assemblies can change the answer, but the insurer decides — and the time to ask is before the material is ordered.

If you are set on cedar, get the insurer’s position in writing first. If the answer is no, an asphalt or metal roof may be the difference between a straightforward policy and a restricted one.

Which roof fits which house

Cedar earns its cost on character homes, on roofs with the structure to carry it, and with owners who will maintain it. It is also repairable and long-lived, which suits people planning to stay.

Asphalt is the sensible default for most modest houses, tight budgets and anyone who wants a low-maintenance roof. It is not a downgrade; it is a different set of trade-offs. The wrong decision is cedar chosen for appearance and then left unmaintained.

Frequently asked

Is a cedar roof worth it in Vancouver?
It can be, if the house suits it, the structure can carry the weight and you will pay for cleaning and treatment every few years. Without maintenance, cedar is the most expensive way to get a short-lived roof.
Does cedar last longer than asphalt in this climate?
Maintained cedar generally does — 30+ years versus roughly 20–25 for asphalt. Neglected cedar under trees can fail at 18–20, which removes the advantage entirely.
Can you switch from cedar to asphalt?
Yes, and it is common. The tear-off removes the weight, the deck is inspected and repaired, and the new assembly is installed with proper underlayment and ventilation. Check the structure and the insurer before deciding.

Related

Free estimate

Questions about your cedar roof?

Leave a number and we will call you back. A measured opinion beats a guess from the street.

Call Now · 778-889-7915Quote